Other Mommy opened in the US today, and the search bar is already full of people who want the book, then the next book. I’m in Texas. The trailer has been on every other pre-roll for weeks. The novel under the movie is Josh Malerman’s Incidents Around the House. If y’all only know him from Bird Box, this is a different scare. Five books. The child. The thing that wants a yes. The house that stopped being safe.
What the movie and the book are actually doing
Incidents Around the House came from Del Rey on June 25, 2024. The hardcover is 384 pages. A paperback followed on June 3, 2025, at 400 pages. Same novel. Don’t fight the page count in the aisle. Bela is eight, and she narrates. Her people are Mommy, Daddo, and Grandma Ruth. Ursula and Russ are the names on the paperwork. The other presence in the house isn’t a person. Bela named her Other Mommy. She comes out of the closet. She asks, over and over, if she can go inside Bela’s heart. The Penguin Random House jacket puts the marriage on the table with the monster: the bonds of family are supposed to keep Bela safe, and other incidents show the cracks. I’m not going to tell you what a yes costs. If you want that, read the novel with the lights where you like them.
Malerman told The Hollywood Reporter he left the filmmakers a note. Don’t burn the movie on parents arguing about whether Bela made it up. Everybody believes her, fast. Otherwise half the story is an imaginary friend. The scare is a family that already knows, and still has to sleep there.
The seed is a bedtime. More than a decade before the novel, his brother told him about a child saying goodnight to “Other Mommy.” Malerman put that at the front and built the rest. He said so to The Nerd Daily, and iHorror ran the quote on October 8, 2026.
Other Mommy is directed by Rob Savage (Host, The Boogeyman), script by Nathan Elston. James Wan produced it through Blumhouse and Atomic Monster. Universal opened it in the US on October 9, 2026, 93 minutes, after a date that used to say May. Jessica Chastain plays Ursula and the entity, so the poster can be a mother’s double. Arabella Olivia Clark is Bela. Jay Duplass is Russ. Karen Allen is Grandma Ruth. They shot in Dublin, May through July 2025. The project kept the novel’s title until July 2025, then took the two words from the bedtime. Wikipedia and IMDb agree on the cast and the day. Opening-week reviews have been cold. I’d still read the novel before a second viewing. The film is a cut. The book is Bela’s mouth.
The movie has a star who can play both, so you get a double. In the novel, the name does a lot of that work, and the entity doesn’t keep one fixed look. Defector, the week before release, put it cleanly: it looks like her mother, mostly, and sometimes. I won’t describe the rest. If that trailer face is why you searched, Coraline is here for it.
Awards, so this isn’t only a tie-in sticker. Nominated for the 2024 Bram Stoker Award for Superior Achievement in a Novel. Finalist for the 2025 Locus Award for Best Horror Novel. Publishers Weekly called the scares familiar and still eerie, and said Bela’s voice freshens the premise. Neil McRobert put it on Esquire’s best horror of 2024. Library Journal pointed readers toward Paul Tremblay and Neil Gaiman, which is why two of these five were never a reach.
Bird Box is the other Malerman adaptation people already know: don’t look, and a mother rows blindfolded. It sits on our best horror thrillers list. Survival rules. This list is the closet and the family. I left Bird Box off the five on purpose.
How I scored five, and left the novel off the board
Full weights are on how we rank: critical 25%, readers 25%, craft 20%, originality 15%, accessibility 15%. A movie-week list isn’t the all-time horror shelf. I used the same split I used for the Verity readalikes, with this book’s DNA in the 40%.
A child, or a child’s eyes, on a house that has stopped being safe. Bela is eight and she is the camera. Age isn’t the trick. The vocabulary is.
An entity that wants a parent’s place, or a yes. She asks to come inside Bela’s heart. The match is a want, not a jump. Something is trying to join the family, replace a mother, or get permission.
A family already cracked. The jacket doesn’t wait for the monster to ruin a perfect marriage. The cracks are already there.
Forty percent that DNA, 30% quality on the v1.0 weights, 30% whether someone who just saw the film will finish the book. Malerman stays off the board. Shelves if you wander: horror thriller, supernatural thriller, psychological thriller. Room is the third shelf, and the card says so before you buy it.
Other Mommy DNA, in one table
| Element | What the novel does | Closest match here |
|---|---|---|
| The witness | An eight-year-old tells it | A Head Full of Ghosts, Room |
| The ask | Come inside, or come closer | Come Closer, Coraline |
| The other mother | A double that wants the child’s yes | Coraline, The Exorcist |
| The cracked house | The marriage is already in trouble | A Head Full of Ghosts, Come Closer |
| The vocabulary | A child without adult words for it | Room |
The house that already believes her
These two are the core. Start here if the family, not the poster, is what you took home.
A Head Full of Ghosts (#1) is the one I’d put in your hands in the parking lot. Paul Tremblay, William Morrow, June 2, 2015. The hardcover we link is 304 pages. Merry is eight. Her sister Marjorie is fourteen. Their parents are John and Sarah. Marjorie may be sick, or she may be hosting something, and a reality show called The Possession moves cameras into a Massachusetts house because a haunting that might be an illness is also a show. Fifteen years later, Merry is the one telling it. Tremblay won the 2015 Bram Stoker Award for a novel with this book. Goodreads hangs around 3.8. Kirkus lays out the show, the eight-year-old, and the interview fifteen years later, and it credits the suspense.
I rank it first because the haunted object is the family. The monster has a name, the marriage was already a problem, and a child has the clearest view and the smallest vocabulary. Tremblay adds a camera crew that needs the trouble to keep looking like a series. The later frame slows you down if you wanted a straight haunting. I like the look back. It makes you hold two versions of a little sister’s memory. I’m not going to tell you which version wins.
Come Closer (#2) is the ask, stripped to one night. Sara Gran, Soho Press, 2003. The hardcover we link is ISBN 1569473285, and the product page lists 168 pages. You can finish it before bed. Amanda is an architect. Her husband is Ed. A tapping starts in the apartment. A book about possession shows up in the mail, sent to her by mistake. The demon has a name, Naamah. Kirkus set the novel next to The Yellow Wallpaper and Rosemary’s Baby, which is the right neighborhood: a woman, a marriage, a presence that might be the house and might be her. Goodreads sits around 3.6. Fair. It’s a knife, not a comfort read.
The title is the sentence Other Mommy keeps speaking. Come closer. Come inside. Gran writes the adult on the far side of that sentence, so you lose Bela’s vocabulary and gain a woman who can feel the marriage move. I won’t walk you through what Amanda does once the door is open. The card says possession, violence, and harm to a child. If the 2003 hardcover is priced like a collectible, Soho reprinted a paperback in September 2023. I linked the US edition I could confirm. Kirkus counted that Soho book at 160 pages. The product page for the same ISBN lists 168. The card follows the page we link.
If the other mother is why you bought the ticket
The next two are what a trailer-search actually wants. I ranked them under the family books because DNA isn’t the same thing as a poster.
Coraline (#3) is the other mother, and I’m not going to pretend a children’s book snuck in by accident. Neil Gaiman, 2002. The HarperCollins paperback we link, ISBN 0380807343, is the August 5, 2003 reprint, 208 pages. The story itself is shorter. The extras pad the edition. Coraline has moved to a new flat. A door opens on another house, with an other mother and an other father who want her to stay. Staying means being changed. The book won the 2003 Hugo and Nebula for best novella, and the 2002 Bram Stoker for best work for young readers. Goodreads has sat around 4.1 across an enormous pile of ratings. Library Journal already told Malerman’s readers to look toward Gaiman. The movie crowd was going to land here anyway.
Coraline is a fable with a door. Malerman’s novel is a school night in a marriage that was already loud, told by an eight-year-old the adults believe. The other mother’s want is the shared gear. The life around it isn’t. Read this if the trailer is why you searched. Then go to Tremblay if you want the cameras, the parents, and the bills still in the room on Monday.
The Exorcist (#4) is the old template, and the accessibility score is doing a lot of the work. William Peter Blatty, 1971. The Harper paperback we link is the 40th anniversary edition, ISBN 006209436X, 400 pages, in print from the 2011 reissue. Regan MacNeil is eleven. Her mother, Chris, is an actress. The house is in Georgetown. When the parents’ version of medicine runs out, two priests get the call. The novel has always pointed back at a 1940s possession case. You know the film. That’s why a person walking out of a 2026 theater can start this tonight without a syllabus.
It sits under Tremblay and Gran on purpose. The entity wants a child, the parents can’t fix it, and the house stops being a house. The fight is a church, more than an other mother asking to join the family. Other Mommy is meaner about the marriage and softer on the theology. I’m not going to describe what the possession does to Regan. The warnings say sexual violence because the book contains it. If that’s a stop, skip to Room or back to Come Closer. If it isn’t, this is still the book people mean by a child in the house and a thing the adults can’t bargain with.
The voice, when there’s no ghost
Room (#5) is the technique, and I ranked it last so the label is visible before the buy button. Emma Donoghue, Little, Brown, first edition September 13, 2010. The hardcover we link is ISBN 0316098337, 336 pages, which matches Kirkus. Jack is five. He and Ma live in a shed eleven feet by eleven feet. Ma was taken at nineteen. Seven years. The man is Old Nick. Every page is Jack’s voice, and he doesn’t have adult words for what the room is. The novel was shortlisted for the 2010 Booker Prize. Goodreads sits around 4.1. The prose earns the score.
There’s no entity in this book. The horror is a man, a lock, and a life so small a child thinks those walls are the world. Fifth place is the label: buy it for the voice, not for another haunting. The match is Bela’s mouth. She names the worst thing in the house with the words she has. Jack’s dictionary is even smaller. He can say Room. Both sentences are too small for what’s inside them. Ma makes a plan that needs him. I won’t tell you the plan. The child’s point of view doesn’t erase the warnings. Kidnapping, captivity, sexual violence, confinement. It changes how the sentences land.
How I’d pick, if I were standing in the aisle
| If you want this | Start here | Then try |
|---|---|---|
| The family under the entity | A Head Full of Ghosts | The Exorcist |
| The ask, tonight | Come Closer | Coraline |
| The other mother from the poster | Coraline | A Head Full of Ghosts |
| The child the parents can’t fix | The Exorcist | A Head Full of Ghosts |
| The way a kid tells it | Room | The Malerman novel |
Read the novel before a second viewing. Give the film its 93 minutes, then give Bela a night. Y’all who clicked for the double on the poster can start at Coraline and climb to Tremblay. I’d still start at A Head Full of Ghosts. Same age in the house. A family that still has to eat dinner while something in the bedroom wants an answer.
Related rankings on ThrillerRanked
Malerman’s other engine, the blindfold and the rowboat, is on best horror thrillers. Once the cracked parents or Room are the gear you liked, move to best psychological thrillers and best domestic suspense. A different movie-week list, hired writer and manuscript, is books like Verity. Useful in the lobby. Wrong closet.
One and two for the family. Three for the other mother, if a children’s book is allowed. Four for the cathedral, if you can stand the warnings. Five for the voice, when a ghost would only get in the way.